Carrie UnderWeight?

16. CArrie Underwood is beautiful no matter what she weighs!!!! She is a class-act .....so gracious and beautiful all the time. What a whirlwind year she has had.......keeping that busy is enough to make anyone shed 10 pounds.....I don't think it was intentional - she has said that she just doesn't have alot of time to sit around and eat.
America got it right and she is just a STAR - I love her and can't wait for her next CD......great outfit too!

Posted at 10:28AM on Mar 9th 2007 by lynn

17. And I want to add........thank goodness for American Idol because we might not have been blessed with Carrie Underwood without this opportunity she was given.

Posted at 10:31AM on Mar 9th 2007 by lynn

18. She looks beautiful both ways!!

The moment entertaining moment of this dull AI season was having her come back for 5 minutes.

Posted at 10:35AM on Mar 9th 2007 by anna

19. I have always liked Carrie Underwood. She looked and sang great last night. The only thing I noticed was that she looked bored to be there. Or a little to big headed maybe. Not sure, she just didn't smile a whole lot and looked a little pushed out of shape to be there.

Posted at 10:34AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Cindy

20. She's thinner because she is no longer eating fatty animal products (like meat). I went on the Macrobiotic diet 2 years ago and lost so much weight, but I was healthier.

She does look thin, but I wouldn't say she was fat before hand.

Posted at 10:37AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Cote

21. She looks good BUT she shouldn't lose anymore weight. She is thinner than she was but I don't think she is rail thin, again, she can't lose too much more weight without looking too thin. This could be a change of diet also.

Posted at 10:38AM on Mar 9th 2007 by My2cents

22. She is beautiful either way and so talented. I love her music!

Posted at 10:44AM on Mar 9th 2007 by K. Jackson

23. Carrie is the BEST American Idol winner ever! She was a star that definately needed to be discovered. She is beautiful, extremely talented and a true "young lady" in every aspect! And didnt even have to take her close off or act like a slut to get noticed. More young women should follow her example. I have nothing but respect for her and she deserves all high honors!

Posted at 4:50PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Sam

24. She is NOT attractive at all, skinny or chunky. Yuck.

Posted at 10:48AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Rudy

25. When she walked out to sing it's the first thing I said. OMG whats happened to Carrie? She's way too thin. It's so sad that these young girls think they need to be so thin to be successful. She was far more beautiful with some more weight on her. The girl needs to look towards Jennifer Hudson, Jennifer Lopez or Beyonce for role models. At least they haven't succumbed to the pressure to be too thin.

Posted at 10:48AM on Mar 9th 2007 by susan

26. She is beautiful either way. It is a simple fact that if you are famous you are held to a ridiculous standard when it comes to weight. She was probably told by many people to lose weight, what must that do to your brain??!! She is so talented and that should be the focus.

Posted at 11:18AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Jennifer

27. Coke will do that to you . Next time get a Coke-lite .

Posted at 1:43PM on Mar 9th 2007 by The REAL thing

28. Carrie Underwood is a superstar. She has never looked more beautiful. She isnt too skinny she has just lost her baby fat and is now a stunning woman.

Posted at 11:00AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Buck

29. The problem is American's are so fixated on weight. Who's too fat? Who's too thin? Who the hell cares? While we criticize celebrities and how they handle their own weight, we're sitting behind our computers stuffing ourselves with junk and getting fatter and fatter with every keystroke.

At the end of the day, all that should matter as far as these celebrities are concerned is the talent and the quality of entertainment they bring to us, which in the case of Miss Carrie Underwood last night was not all that great. That song was terrible.


Now everyone go have a candy bar and have a great day!

Posted at 10:59AM on Mar 9th 2007 by teendav8

30. Carrie Underwood is a star. She is older now, and probably more conscious of her weight. When you make personal appearances all over the country you are exhausted. She is thinner, but looks very healthy........and beautiful.

Posted at 11:11AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Paul Kline