Carrie UnderWeight?

121. i think she looks best skinny. and good for her she lost the weight but she doesnt look too skinny. i am not saying she looked bad in the first place. shes looked amazing all along. and of course the pictures they show of her, in her old one she is smilining like she is ready where as in the more recent one she is not ready so it will not look as great. stop judging others for gods sake :)

Posted at 8:21PM on Mar 12th 2007 by hanna

122. What bother's me is that they call her old look "plump". She was skinny then, now she is way too skinny. I dont get what the craze is to weigh in at under 100.

I love her singing abilities and her personality but I just hope that she doesnt turn into a Nicole Richie (her size, that is..)

Posted at 3:45PM on Mar 12th 2007 by amanda

123. It is entirely possible that Carrie has not lost any weight but has gotten rid of some body fat and toned up a little. Even at that, she is smiling and has her arms pressed next to her body in the "plump" picture and is the opposite way in the other. The photos are also from different angles. Hmmm... possible optical illusion?

Posted at 3:44PM on Mar 12th 2007 by Kate

124. I saw Her The night of Her Birthday . I Live in Nashville She was At Grahams and was so Beauitful I thought She looked very Heathly Tone and Happy and was Having just a Good Time so I think She is looking Great!!!

Posted at 4:55PM on Mar 12th 2007 by Amanda

125. Carrie Underwood is beautiful either way. I think she looks healthy and fine. I don't think we should be concerned about her weight. She is smart and knows what's best for her. She is def. thinner, but she's healthy.. looks beautiful as always.. and sounds amazing!

* some of these comments are really really rude. I don't understand why people have to put down Carrie like this. She is the sweetest young woman I have ever met.. she has done nothing wrong. Carrie's amazing, enough said.

Posted at 5:07PM on Mar 14th 2007 by Meg

126. She wasn't even "plump" before.
She looked great, and she still does.
Carrie is naturally beautiful, and she didn't need to lose weight, for whatever reason she did. Intentional or not.

Posted at 2:54PM on Mar 14th 2007 by Melissa

127. I'm pretty sure the constant touring she's been doing since winning Idol and releasing a hit record had a lot to do with the weight loss. It happens to every performer, being that it's impossible to put on a good, high energy show without using your own energy. It's normal for any performer.
So boo to all of you who think she made a choice to lose weight in order to "fit in" with public idealistic perceptions.

Posted at 12:28AM on Mar 13th 2007 by Joe

128. Carrie is one of the MOST talented female singers ever!
She may have lost a couple pounds running around with everything she is doing,
but I do not think she is anerexic(however you spell it)!!LOL

Also she was never ever fat she was a normal sized girl! NEVER PLUMP!!!

Posted at 6:51PM on Mar 12th 2007 by tennisboy511

129. Actually..........i looked at the two photos again and i see there is blue smuge marks all around her arms!!! Look if you dont believe me!!! I think the photo is soooo fake!! i love carrie!

Posted at 8:06PM on Mar 12th 2007 by tennisboy511

130. i think she has lost WAY too much weight and she is grosely skinny...she needs to gain some weight back to look good again...she made want to puke up all my insides...

Posted at 3:14PM on Mar 13th 2007 by Alysha

131. Carrie Underwood is the best American Idol and one of the most talented female artists in the music industry today!!! The thought of people thinking she was anerexic (however you spell it) makes me want to barf!!! I have seen interviews of her when she was asked about her wait loss and she has been working out to stay healthy and stay fit. Is there a law against being healthy that I dont know about? The picture they used of her is a bad picture anyway to make people believe what they said, it is a disgrace!!! I still love Carrie Underwood and feel sorry for her that someone would make something like this up, when she worked so hard to lose wait they accuse her of being anerexic!!! It is a shame!!!!!!

Posted at 7:11PM on Mar 12th 2007 by Will Garner

132. Carrie is a class act. Her humble real world persona has rocketed her to stardom.

Posted at 7:51PM on Mar 12th 2007 by Johnny

133. I take my hat off to her...she has accomplished alot...she does look like she has lost weight..and looks tired. .she probably just doesnt have time to eat with all that she has going on...(awards, concerts etc)..but all i can say though to you loyal fans of hers should start letting her know to take a bit time out if she gets a chance for some well deserved R&R....because if she doesnt she may just end up burning herself out too soon....and that my friends would be awful....as far as I know she is starting to work on another CD and that alone says STRESS in itself with videos as well and we all know that making videos are a very LONG process to do...Best of luck to her.

Posted at 8:01PM on Mar 12th 2007 by Pebbles

134. she looks best plump y starve yourself 2 look like the nasty olsen twins more guys lik a little junk in the trunk then nothin @ all carrie looks great so just leave her alone more pressure would just stress her more

Posted at 8:58PM on Mar 12th 2007 by wiggles

135. Carrie:

You are beautiful...You don't need to lose weight. I voted for you all the way thru American Idol bought your CD. Your My IDOL...

Posted at 9:24PM on Mar 12th 2007 by Lenny B